1.12.10
Practical Comparison of Decoding Methods
What is it?
Different decoding methods offer different trade-offs between determinism, diversity, output quality and computation. The best choice depends on the generation task rather than one method being universally superior.
Key points
Greedy: deterministic, no diversity; useful for code and factual QA. Beam search: deterministic with narrow diversity; useful for translation and summarization. Diverse beam search: generates varied candidates for reranking. Top-k: general-purpose sampling. Top-p: adaptive sampling and a common choice for open-ended tasks. Min-p: adaptive alternative to top-p. Contrastive decoding: aims for highly coherent and factual output but requires two models.
Choosing a Decoding Strategy
For a factual question, greedy decoding may be sufficient. For translation, beam search can explore several likely sequences. For creative writing, top-p sampling with a higher temperature can produce more varied text. For candidate reranking, diverse beam search can generate different alternatives.
Real-world application
Select decoding settings based on the required balance of accuracy, creativity, consistency, latency and computational cost. Test the chosen strategy on representative prompts.
Key takeaway
Decoding strategy changes the character of generated output even when the model and prompt remain the same.